LIVE
GoldSquawk LIVE Live gold news and audio squawk
OpinionArgument and analysis from the Markets Desk

Gold’s physical market is firmer than the futures tape

Monday, Nov. 16, 2026 — Gold has been hit as if a break below $4,000 settled the argument, but the physical-linked signals do not show a clean collapse in bullion demand. The price damage is real, yet Shanghai, warehouse stocks and ETF flows still leave room to challenge the easy bear story.

Warehouse, gold, gold camp, fort knox, illustrating: Gold’s physical market is firmer than the futures tape
Photo: mwewering / Pixabay

Gold has been hit as if a break below $4,000 settled the argument. We do not buy that. The price damage is real, but the physical-linked signals do not show a clean collapse in bullion demand. Spot touched $3,830, the lowest since October 2025, by 20:46 UTC on Monday as a firm US dollar weighed on bullion, while COMEX settled at $3,852.20 on Monday versus $3,886.20 on Thursday, a drop of $34.00, or 0.87%, according to GoldSquawk [H4][S1][S2].

Our view is simple: paper prices are doing more of the damage than the physical chain is confirming. Shanghai still sat above London by $8.60 an ounce on Monday, SHFE gold stocks held at 118.4 tonnes, Au(T+D) turnover stayed heavy, and GLD plus GLDM took in 5.1 tonnes in the latest week, according to GoldSquawk [D5][D6][D7][D10][D1]. That does not prove a physical squeeze. It does show relative resilience, and that is enough to challenge the easy bear story.

The macro bear story is only half the story

The prevailing interpretation is clear. Kitco commentary framed gold’s break under $4,000 around Fed fears, a stronger dollar, higher bond yields and technical damage, with some analysts looking for $3,800 if support failed [R8][R9][R10]. Monday’s market coverage kept the same line, tying the fall to dollar strength as spot hit $3,830 [H4]. That view assumes COMEX weakness is a fair proxy for the wider bullion market.

It is partly right. Futures have plainly broken lower. COMEX traded at $3,877.00 before the first headline on Thursday, printed a rebound high at $3,904.10 late on Sunday, then sank to $3,836.40 early on Monday, a swing of $67.70 from that high to low, or about 1.7%, according to GoldSquawk [P1][P2][P3]. That is not noise.

But the macro explanation is less complete than it looks. The US producer-price release on Thursday was not an obvious fresh inflation shock: headline PPI rose 0.3% against a 0.4% forecast, while core PPI also rose 0.3%, matching the forecast [C1][C2]. When gold still breaks hard after that, we should suspect liquidation and benchmark-driven selling, not just a simple repricing of inflation and Fed risk.

China has not signed off on the collapse

The strongest evidence against a clean physical washout is in Shanghai. The Shanghai Gold Exchange benchmark still stood $8.60 above London spot on Monday, and the seven-day average premium was $2.90, according to GoldSquawk [D5]. Over four weeks, that premium rose from $6.76 to $8.60, an increase of $1.84, or 27.2%, even as COMEX gold futures fell from $4,160.10 to $3,886.30, down 6.6% over the same span [D5]. If benchmark prices are collapsing while Shanghai’s relative price is firmer, the physical side is not echoing the screen.

Activity stayed live too. Au(T+D) open interest was 209,364 lots on Monday, down only 0.4% on the day, while volume reached 70,122 kg, which was 2.0 times its 19-day median, according to Shanghai Gold Exchange [D7]. Delivery was 17,964 lots, turnover was CNY 58.3 billion, and the weighted average price was CNY 831.25 a gram even after the close fell 1.16% to CNY 829.00 [D9][D10]. That is not what a market looks like when participants are stepping away from delivery-linked gold.

SHFE warehouse stocks add another layer. Gold inventories in Shanghai Futures Exchange warehouses held at 118.4 tonnes in the week to 13 November, unchanged on the week, up 1.5 tonnes over four weeks and 4.7 tonnes over 13 weeks, with the latest reading the highest since 14 November 2025 [D6]. We are not calling that tightness. We are saying the Chinese exchange system is still carrying metal and still transacting, even as COMEX has been marked down far more aggressively.

Do not overread the premium

This is where gold bulls can go wrong. The Shanghai premium is not a pure tightness gauge. The World Gold Council’s methodology notes that the premium is the gap between SGE prices and the LBMA Gold Price AM, but it excludes import tariffs, taxes and freight costs, and the Shanghai and London benchmarks differ in specification [R6]. The World Gold Council also warns that the published premium can overstate the realised premium [R6]. So a positive premium is useful evidence, not proof of stress.

The same caution applies to deferred-market signals. On Monday, longs paid shorts for one trading day in a row in the deferral-fee mechanism [D8]. That sounds bullish until you read the exchange rules. The SGE describes the mechanism as a way to address imbalances in physical delivery, and its contract documents make clear that deferred products are margin-traded, marked to market and designed with delivery equalizers built in [R4][R5]. In other words, the fee can reflect market structure as much as scarcity.

That is why our claim is narrower. The evidence does not show a decisive physical squeeze. It shows that physical indicators are holding up better than futures pricing.

What would settle it from here

Western fund flows also refuse the clean-collapse story. GLD and GLDM took in 5.1 tonnes in the latest week, marking three weekly increases in a row [D1]. Even after a four-week outflow of 8.6 tonnes, the 26-week total was still a 34.7-tonne inflow [D1]. At the broader level, global gold ETF holdings stood at 4,275 tonnes at the end of October, up 19 tonnes in the month, with net flows of $2.7 billion, and the World Gold Council treats physically backed ETFs as a major source of gold demand [D4][R7]. That is not uniform capitulation.

If we are right, the break under $4,000 will prove more tactical than structural. Futures have priced the selloff more harshly than the physical market has validated it. That leaves gold vulnerable to more paper weakness if US macro keeps supporting the dollar, with US retail sales due on 17 November forecast at 0.1% headline and 0.4% core, followed by FOMC minutes on 18 November [C7][C8][C11]. But the deeper test is not another chart level. It is whether Shanghai stays above London, whether Au(T+D) turnover and delivery stay active, and whether ETF inflows hold up. If those do, bears will have to explain why the physical market still has not capitulated.

Key data

MeasureValueSource
COMEX settlement drop$3,852.20GoldSquawk settlement data
Shanghai premium+$8.60GoldSquawk data
SHFE gold stocks118.4 tShanghai Futures Exchange weekly warehouse stock report, via GoldSquawk data
Au(T+D) open interest209,364 lotsShanghai Gold Exchange daily report, via GoldSquawk data
GLD plus GLDM weekly flows+5.1 tSPDR Gold Shares, via GoldSquawk data

Primary sources

General market commentary only. Not financial advice.